Thom Lauzon, Gone Too Soon

My late father-in-law was a lifelong Republican, at least until George W. Bush drove him to switch parties. (I’m just glad he didn’t live long enough to suffer the worst excesses of the Trump era.) He was a staunch capitalist who cared deeply about the environment and gave generously to charitable causes. I used to say that if all conservatives were like him, then conservatism might be a workable system. If people of means didn’t mind paying taxes, maintaining environmental standards, and giving to those in need, then the rough edges of capitalism would be much, much smoother.

In a much different way, Thom Lauzon was like my father-in-law. Lauzon died suddenly this morning at age 65, apparently of natural causes. He was a conservative who cared, especially for his adoptive hometown of Barre. He was the city’s longest-serving mayor, its biggest booster, a dominant player in its real estate market, its loudest and most colorful figure, and a close friend of Gov. Phil Scott. If every conservative Republican was like Lauzon, conservatism would work better than it does.

Lauzon could be an overbearing jerk at times. His temper occasionally got the better of him, like when he threw the city manager’s cellphone across the room during a Council meeting, or when he chased down a hit-and-run driver and placed himself in front of the car, or when a guy in a Santa suit tossed a pie in Jim Douglas’ face and Lauzon ran after him and landed a few punches. Or when he proposed 50-year automatic prison sentences for anyone caught selling drugs. But he truly believed in Barre, invested heavily in it when it wasn’t the “smart” thing to do, and spearheaded countless civic improvement projects.

He was also, it’s not terribly surprising to learn, an extremely charitable man who kept his philanthropy on the down-low. Barre realtor and longtime friend John Biondolillo told The Times Argus that “(Lauzon) had a huge heart. He did so much, for so many people, and they never knew who to thank.” And former city manager Steve Mackenzie said Lauzon’s death was “going to leave a horrendous void in the community.”

I’ll also say that although I sometimes wrote unkindly of his excesses, he always treated me with civility. Unlike many Vermonters, he wasn’t troubled by the sharp-elbow approach to politics. He didn’t hold grudges, at least not with me.

But that’s neither here nor there. Thom Lauzon was a giant in Barre politics and business, and a force for its economic development. His death does leave a void in the community, and it robs the Vermont political scene of one of its few truly memorable characters.

Good News! Vermont’s Homelessness Crisis Is [Checks Notes] Slightly Less Awful, By One Questionable Metric

The headlines looked mildly reassuring.

VTDigger and Vermont Public (they co-published a story by Carly Berlin, their shared reporter on housing issues): “Annual count finds slight decline in homelessness in Vermont”

WCAX: “Vermont homelessness count dips as lawmakers debate shelter strategy”

WPTZ: “New data shows 3% decrease in homelessness in Vermont”

So we’ve maybe turned the corner a little bit? Well, yes and no. And no. And no. Mostly, sadly, no.

The stories all cover the 2026 “Point-in-time count,” the annual one-night attempt to count the homeless population. The effort is kind of doomed from the get-go, because the homeless are by definition difficult to find. Every single PIT count is an undercount. But it’s the only tool we have, and it’s a useful measuring stick as long as you don’t treat it as gospel.

It’s true that the new PIT count showed a slight decline in homelessness in Vermont. However…

Continue reading →

We Need to Talk About Suburban Voters (Now With Math Correction)

While I was staring at my computer screen on election night, I noticed what looked like a trend: Amanda Janoo was badly underperforming in the Burlington suburbs. The trend held through the evening and into the final results. This fact alone didn’t sink her campaign, but it blocked any chance she had of winning.

The two Burlington-area maplets above, taken from the Secretary of State’s election results website, tell the story in a glance. On the left is the race for lieutenant governor; if a town is blue, then Molly Gray won a majority of its votes. And yes, they’re all blue. Incumbent LG John Rodgers was skunked. (The tiny red sliver at the top of the LG image is the southern tip of Georgia, the closest Rodgers got to scoring in the Burlington area.) On the right is the governor’s race; the beige towns went for Janoo while the red ones gave majority support to Gov. Phil Scott. Janoo did win in some places, but mainly with very narrow majorities — not nearly enough to offset Republican votes elsewhere in Vermont.

We’re talking reliable Democratic territory here. Republicans are woefully uncompetitive in all but one community, Milton, which largely elected Democrats this time. But the governor did extremely well in the places surrounding Burlington. Shockingly well, compared to the rest of his party’s ticket.

I haven’t done exit polling or convened a focus group, but I can tell you what I think about this. I think these towns are full of affluent liberals whose ideology is tempered by caution, and they voted via their pocketbooks. Janoo advocated progressive ideas including a property tax hike on second homes and a higher tax on incomes over $250,000. I know, tiny violins. But a lot of these people have household incomes north of 250 G’s and maybe own vacation property as well, and I’m sure their property taxes are in nosebleed territory. There was plenty of straight ticket Democratic voting throughout, except for Janoo. And she couldn’t win without their support.

Continue reading →

Armistice Day Bookshelf: The Works of Derek Robinson

It’s been a while since I posted anything in my occasional “Bookshelf” series, spotlighting books I think are worth sharing. But in honor of the November 11 holiday, here’s a bit about a writer I just discovered a couple of years ago.

Derek Robinson is an English author with numerous books to his name. His most enduring works (or they should be if there’s any justice in the world, ha) are six novels about life in wartime, predominantly about the air war. Three are set in World War I, and the other three take place in World War II.

The novels are about how war is a massive meatgrinder that takes a heavy and indiscriminate toll on its participants. Robinson is reflexively compared to Joseph Heller, but that’s off target in some significant ways. “Cath-22” is a deeply cynical work that questions human nature and the entire project of war. Robinson doesn’t really question the necessity (or otherwise) of war; it’s simply a reality that has swallowed up all his characters, very few of whom survive the ordeal. I suspect that if you asked him, Robinson would say the Allies had no choice but to fight the two world wars. The consequences were terrible but unavoidable.

Continue reading →

Hey Ben, Ever Heard of the Phrase “Decent Interval”?

I don’t know about you, but I’m still living in the afterglow of the most positive non-presidential election I’ve experienced since 1974. I was certainly still there on Friday morning, the third day after the election, when Burlington City Council President Ben Traverse just couldn’t wait any longer to launch his campaign for mayor.

And my reaction was, c.mon, couldn’t you let it breathe just a little?

I mean, the political storylines in Vermont included the Democrats and Progressives retaking their legislative supermajorities and gubernatorial candidate Amanda Janoo doing her best to bring people together and erase the differences between Vermonters. A bit of a honeymoon period would have been nice before Traverse pivoted to a candidacy that’s certain to exacerbate the tensions between caucus partners. For starters, he’ll be running against incumbent Progressive Emma Mulvaney-Stanak, assuming she seeks another term. Even if she doesn’t, there’s certain to be a Progressive nominee Traverse will be trying to topple.

There’s also the fact that, since he became the top Democrat in city politics, he’s done his best to be a thorn in the side of the current administration.

That’s all fine. He has every right to run the campaign he wants. People have every right to support him. I just wish he’d held off a bit longer, out of respect to the long campaign season we’d all just been through and to let the good feelings from last Tuesday linger in the air.

Plus, I don’t understand the rush. City elections are almost four months away, longer than the general election season we just exited. Party caucuses are in December, but I doubt that Traverse will have serious competition for his party’s nomination or any real trouble fundraising among the real estate/developer/deep pocketed business types who will surely flock to his banner. (Get your checkbooks ready, Pomerleaus, Tarrants, Pizzagallis, Bissonettes, Boardmans, et al.)

Continue reading →

At Least She’s Taking It Well

Hey everybody, meet Stephanie Mack, Republican candidate for Vermont House in the Chittenden-24 district. She ran against incumbent Democrat Alyssa Black and lost by more than 20 percentage points. (“Erik Post” was a Dem candidate in the neighboring Chittenden-23 district. Does Mack know who she was running against?) Apparently she’s taken her loss poorly; she wrote a lengthy post on her campaign’s Facebook page bemoaning the dominance of Democrats and predicting a coming “civil revolution.”

After a while she apparently had second thoughts and removed the post. Fortunately, I have screenshots. Funny thing is, she wrote a new post that’s much, much worse. It casts doubt on the 2026 election results and urges Trump to take control of the election system. It’s January 6 all over again, except without the feces-smearing and general mayhem. I think.

And she wonders why she couldn’t appeal to voters in a deep blue district.

Her initial post in more detail. She bemoans the fact that she couldn’t draw any more votes than her predecessor. In fact, 2024 was a Republican wave election. If she got as many votes in 2026 as a Republican drew in 2024, she actually did pretty well. Especially since 2024 was a presidential year and a lot more people voted. This is one accountant who seems unfamiliar with the use of numbers.

Mack centered her campaign on her professional experience in accountancy. She called for a complete audit of the entire state government, a notion that would induce a horse laugh from Auditor Doug Hoffer. He’s been auditing bits and pieces of the government full-time for nearly 14 years and hasn’t come anywhere close to exploring the whole thing.

Also, her audit demand ought to be addressed to Gov. Phil Scott, who’s been running the state for a decade and is in the best position to do what she wants. But her grasp on how government works, not to mention her grip on reality, seems a little shaky. In this context it should be noted that she has yet to file the campaign finance report due on October 30, which undercuts her claim to fiscal probity.

Continue reading →

I Come Not to Bury Amanda Janoo, But to Praise Her

There are two very different interpretations of Amanda Janoo’s candidacy for governor. It was one of the most brilliant surprises in the recent history of Vermont politics, or it was a lucky accident. Janoo herself? Emerging superstar, or flash in the pan.

It’s a mix of the two, really. My recipe is more of the former with a dash of the latter. I hope this isn’t the end of her electoral career. I hope to see more of her in the near future, including another run for governor in 2028. In fact, she ought to be considered the early favorite for the Democratic nomination because (1) she shows great promise and (2) she had the ovaries to challenge Scott when better-known politicians ran away and hid. Her courage merits reward, not punishment.

So let’s expand on the two interpretations, starting with the positive. Janoo entered the race with an impressive if unconventional resumé. She was born and raised in Vermont, but her professional career has taken place elsewhere. She had never run for office or worked in a government job, but she has developed policy and advised officials on how to implement progressive ideas. It’s a profession that requires well-developed political muscles.

But pretty much nobody in Democratic circles knew much about her. From essentially zero, she accomplished something close to miraculous this year. To begin with, she faced a primary opponent who was better connected in political and donor circles, and she won.

That’s when the hard part began. She faced Gov. Phil Scott, a well-known incumbent with an unbroken record of electoral triumph. She had very little money left over from the primary. She was trying to introduce herself to a much broader electorate during a short general election season, and she couldn’t afford a TV ad blitz that could narrow the familiarity gap. Her fundraising prospects were not great.

But then something started happening.

Continue reading →

There’s a New Contender for Worst Job in Vermont

And no, it’s not janitor at the stinky, crowded, dangerous women’s prison. Nor is it rescue designer for the Bennington Battle Monument. Nor is it doing debate prep for Gov. Phil Scott. Nope, the clear front-runner for worst job in Vermont is… chair of the Vermont Republican Party.

The not-so-G.O.P. exited Election Night with troubles all around: a calamitous outcome for every Republican not named “Phil Scott,” legislators facing two years in the superminority wilderness, a chronic money shortage, a dearth of competitive candidates, an extremist-riddled party hierarchy, the only popular guy likely to exit in 2028, and that guy’s most obvious successor freshly blasted into political oblivion.

Otherwise, Mrs. Lincoln, it’s a great gig.

Let’s take ’em one at a time. First, while Scott prevailed by about six percentage points — the smallest margin he’s enjoyed in any of his nine statewide campaigns — the rest of the Republican statewide ticket was decimated and the combined Democratic/Progressive caucuses will hold supermajorities in the House and Senate. It was a worst-case scenario for every Republican except Scott and a complete undoing of the VTGOP’s gains in the 2024 election, which now seems to have been a Trump-fueled aberration instead of a permanent rightward shift.

Continue reading →

Phil Scott Survives the Blue Tsunami, May Come to Regret It

The blue wave crashed over every Republican breakwall just about everywhere. Nationally, the Democrats are on track to win lopsided majorities in both houses of Congress and are picking up governorships by the bushel. I’m old enough to have voted in the 1974 post-Watergate wave election; 2026 is on track to be a better night for Democrats.

Here in Vermont, only Gov. Phil Scott survived. He won by a seven-point margin over Democrat Amanda Janoo, but he will be a severely weakened force heading into his sixth (and presumably final) term. His reputed successor, Lt. Gov. John Rodgers, got literally and figuratively mollywhopped and will not be returning to Montpelier.

The big thing for Vermont is that the combined Democratic/Progressive caucuses will hold supermajorities in the House and Senate. We’re looking at a complete reversal of the 2024 Republican advance — and maybe even more.

Quite a few legislative races have yet to be called, but here’s where things stand as of right now. In the Senate, the Democrats have won 19 seats and have a solid lead in a 20th (Orange). Progressive Sen. Tanya Vyhovsky will caucus with them, so that’s 21 seats. Independent Dave Wolk picked off a seat in formerly deep red Rutland, sending *alleged* daughter-puncher Sen. Terry Williams to the showers. Wolk is a former Democratic senator, so he might be expected to caucus with the Democrats.

As for Senate Republicans… they only have seven wins, plus Minority Leader Scott Beck has a narrow lead over Democrat David Roth,so they might end up with eight.

Continue reading →

For Republicans Not Named Phil Scott, the Light at the End of the Tunnel is a Train (Or, Liveblogging Part the Last)

10:34 p.m. Sorry, I took a break to check out the national returns. And not much changed in the meantime; the trends that have been forming for a couple of hours are still holding true. Here’s how things look right now:

Phil Scott’s winning again. Amanda Janoo has been slowly taking nibbles out of his lead, but he’s still 5.7 points ahead with 88% of the votes counted. She’s going to come closer to beating Scott than anyone else on Planet Earth, but she’s not gonna win.

Otherwise, this election could hardly have gone worse for Scott and the VTGOP. Lt. Gov. John Rodgers is getting his clock cleaned. He’s barely running ahead of the no-hopers on the Republican statewide ticket. He is decidedly not the Republicans’ hope for a governor to succeed Scott.

We’re going back to Democratic supermajorities. It looks very much like the Democrats will take back all or almost all the ground they lost in 2024. It looks very much like they will again hold supermajorities in both legislative chambers.

Rural Vermont Rising was a flash in the pan, not a growing force in Vermont politics. Leaving aside the question of whether rural Vermont has been getting the shaft (and I believe there’s a good argument that they have not), they’re getting their collective asses kicked in this election. RVR was seen as a movement on the rise after 2024, but their momentum is all gone after tonight.

Now back to the liveblogging, at least for a while. We’re getting to the point where the big questions are close to being answered, but let’s root around in the returns and see if there’s anything happening.

10:45 p.m. Phil Scott’s middle name must be “sui generis.” He is truly one of a kind. He has a unique hold on the voting public in Vermont. They stick with him through thick and thin. He has run for office in every election since 2000, and he has yet to be defeated. He is the only person to win six terms as Vermont governor. I’m pretty sure Janoo will come closer to beating him than any other candidate ever.

At the same time, the voters are once again making it clear that generally speaking, they favor the Democratic Party over the Republicans. It’ll be interesting to see if Scott tries to claim a mandate if he wins narrowly while the VTGOP takes an historic shellacking.

10:49 p.m. Early prediction for 2028: Phil Scott will not seek a seventh term. Janoo will run again, and should be considered the early favorite in a dogpile of a Democratic primary.

10:50 p.m. The two constitutional amendments are sailing to passage by lopsided margins. Prop 3 has 74% of the vote, and Prop 4 has 79%.

10:51 p.m. Nothing has changed in the state Senate races. The Democrats are still on track to pick up four seats, while the Republicans are likely to lose five. Republican Senators on their way out include Steven Heffernan of Addison, Pat Brennan of Grand Isle, John Benson of Orange, and alleged daughter-puncher Terry Williams of Rutland (who would be replaced by independent Dave Wolk). Rep. Ashley Bartley has apparently fallen short in her bid to win the Chittenden North Senate seat. The new Senate would include 21 Dems and Progs, eight Repubs, and one independent.

10:55 p.m. In the House, likely Republican losers include Rob North, Jim Casey, Mary Morrissey (!!!), Sandra Pinsonault, Debra Powers, Mike Southworth, Brenda Steady, Anthony Micklus, Kumulia Long, Joe Luneau, John Brigham, Richard Bailey, Kevin Winter, Michael Boutin, and Tom Charlton. Mind you, those are only the incumbents on their way to defeat. Some first-time candidates have lost Republican seats as well. Rep. Michael Morgan looks to have survived the devastation by the hairs on his chinny-chin-chin. If any. Necessary caveat: There’s a very good chance of a surprise comeback or two in the legislative races. But the shape and scope of the results are established beyond challenge.

11:04 p.m. Yeah, I’m ready to call it for Phil Scott even if the Associated Press isn’t there yet. With 92% of the vote counted, he’s 5.7 points ahead of Amanda Janoo. This will, in fact, be the closest contest Phil Scott has ever been in. For those who want to being parsing the results, here’s the latest iteration of the Secretary of State’s heatmap, showing which communities went for which candidate and by how much. The bigger and darker the circle, the more decisive the margin.

On the live version, available on the Vermont Public election page, you can click on each town or city and see exactly how they voted. But you can eyeball this map and tell where each candidate was strong. For Janoo, the Connecticut River Valley, Burlington, Winooski, and Montpelier. For Scott, Rutland and Franklin counties plus the Northeast Kingdom and his working-class stomping grounds in central Vermont.

11:11 p.m. The AP has called victory for both constitutional amendments. It has yet to call any statewide races besides U.S. Rep. Becca Balint’s, which I guess is because there’s still a mathematical possibility of a reversal. But the races for lieutenant governor, attorney general, auditor, secretary of state and treasurer have never, ever been close.

11:12 p.m. Things are settled enough for me to hang up my blogger hat for the night. I’m sorry about Janoo, who put everything she had into the race and broke through the Democrats’ aversion for their own gubernatorial candidates. She ran a hell of a race on her own terms. Post-mortems are for tomorrow. I’ll see you then.