Gov. Phil Scott just announced a couple of cabinet appointments that illustrate one of the problems with long-serving governors: Their best people move on, and the talent pool shrinks until it’s shallow and brackish.
This tendency is magnified with Scott because, throughout his tenure, he has usually played “next person up” when there’s a top-level vacancy. The deputy replaces a departed boss, or an established functionary moves from one place to another. Rarely has Scott hired from outside since he first assembled his team. The advantages are familiarity and loyalty. The disadvantage, if you do it over and over again, is you wind up with under-qualified people in critical positions.
It gets worse when a governor has already served multiple terms, because the gravy train is about to end its run. With Scott about to begin his all-time record sixth term (and having reportedly been reluctant to run for re-election this year), why would any qualified candidate with options choose to join a team likely to be disbanded in two years or less? You wind up shuffling and recycling because your options are few.
Which brings me to the 1969 pop nonfiction best-seller The Peter Principle. Its theory (originally meant to be satirical) was that in large organizations, good employees will earn promotions until they reach their level of incompetence. Then, if they’re terrible they get fired, but if they’re kind of adequate they’ll stick around. After a while, your entire team is full of people who can’t quite handle their jobs.
While I was staring at my computer screen on election night, I noticed what looked like a trend: Amanda Janoo was badly underperforming in the Burlington suburbs. The trend held through the evening and into the final results. This fact alone didn’t sink her campaign, but it blocked any chance she had of winning.
The two Burlington-area maplets above, taken from the Secretary of State’s election results website, tell the story in a glance. On the left is the race for lieutenant governor; if a town is blue, then Molly Gray won a majority of its votes. And yes, they’re all blue. Incumbent LG John Rodgers was skunked. (The tiny red sliver at the top of the LG image is the southern tip of Georgia, the closest Rodgers got to scoring in the Burlington area.) On the right is the governor’s race; the beige towns went for Janoo while the red ones gave majority support to Gov. Phil Scott. Janoo did win in some places, but mainly with very narrow majorities — not nearly enough to offset Republican votes elsewhere in Vermont.
We’re talking reliable Democratic territory here. Republicans are woefully uncompetitive in all but one community, Milton, which largely elected Democrats this time. But the governor did extremely well in the places surrounding Burlington. Shockingly well, compared to the rest of his party’s ticket.
I haven’t done exit polling or convened a focus group, but I can tell you what I think about this. I think these towns are full of affluent liberals whose ideology is tempered by caution, and they voted via their pocketbooks. Janoo advocated progressive ideas including a property tax hike on second homes and a higher tax on incomes over $250,000. I know, tiny violins. But a lot of these people have household incomes north of 250 G’s and maybe own vacation property as well, and I’m sure their property taxes are in nosebleed territory. There was plenty of straight ticket Democratic voting throughout, except for Janoo. And she couldn’t win without their support.
There are two very different interpretations of Amanda Janoo’s candidacy for governor. It was one of the most brilliant surprises in the recent history of Vermont politics, or it was a lucky accident. Janoo herself? Emerging superstar, or flash in the pan.
It’s a mix of the two, really. My recipe is more of the former with a dash of the latter. I hope this isn’t the end of her electoral career. I hope to see more of her in the near future, including another run for governor in 2028. In fact, she ought to be considered the early favorite for the Democratic nomination because (1) she shows great promise and (2) she had the ovaries to challenge Scott when better-known politicians ran away and hid. Her courage merits reward, not punishment.
So let’s expand on the two interpretations, starting with the positive. Janoo entered the race with an impressive if unconventional resumé. She was born and raised in Vermont, but her professional career has taken place elsewhere. She had never run for office or worked in a government job, but she has developed policy and advised officials on how to implement progressive ideas. It’s a profession that requires well-developed political muscles.
But pretty much nobody in Democratic circles knew much about her. From essentially zero, she accomplished something close to miraculous this year. To begin with, she faced a primary opponent who was better connected in political and donor circles, and she won.
That’s when the hard part began. She faced Gov. Phil Scott, a well-known incumbent with an unbroken record of electoral triumph. She had very little money left over from the primary. She was trying to introduce herself to a much broader electorate during a short general election season, and she couldn’t afford a TV ad blitz that could narrow the familiarity gap. Her fundraising prospects were not great.
The not-so-G.O.P. exited Election Night with troubles all around: a calamitous outcome for every Republican not named “Phil Scott,” legislators facing two years in the superminority wilderness, a chronic money shortage, a dearth of competitive candidates, an extremist-riddled party hierarchy, the only popular guy likely to exit in 2028, and that guy’s most obvious successor freshly blasted into political oblivion.
Otherwise, Mrs. Lincoln, it’s a great gig.
Let’s take ’em one at a time. First, while Scott prevailed by about six percentage points — the smallest margin he’s enjoyed in any of his nine statewide campaigns — the rest of the Republican statewide ticket was decimated and the combined Democratic/Progressive caucuses will hold supermajorities in the House and Senate. It was a worst-case scenario for every Republican except Scott and a complete undoing of the VTGOP’s gains in the 2024 election, which now seems to have been a Trump-fueled aberration instead of a permanent rightward shift.
The blue wave crashed over every Republican breakwall just about everywhere. Nationally, the Democrats are on track to win lopsided majorities in both houses of Congress and are picking up governorships by the bushel. I’m old enough to have voted in the 1974 post-Watergate wave election; 2026 is on track to be a better night for Democrats.
Here in Vermont, only Gov. Phil Scott survived. He won by a seven-point margin over Democrat Amanda Janoo, but he will be a severely weakened force heading into his sixth (and presumably final) term. His reputed successor, Lt. Gov. John Rodgers, got literally and figuratively mollywhopped and will not be returning to Montpelier.
The big thing for Vermont is that the combined Democratic/Progressive caucuses will hold supermajorities in the House and Senate. We’re looking at a complete reversal of the 2024 Republican advance — and maybe even more.
Quite a few legislative races have yet to be called, but here’s where things stand as of right now. In the Senate, the Democrats have won 19 seats and have a solid lead in a 20th (Orange). Progressive Sen. Tanya Vyhovsky will caucus with them, so that’s 21 seats. Independent Dave Wolk picked off a seat in formerly deep red Rutland, sending *alleged* daughter-puncher Sen. Terry Williams to the showers. Wolk is a former Democratic senator, so he might be expected to caucus with the Democrats.
As for Senate Republicans… they only have seven wins, plus Minority Leader Scott Beck has a narrow lead over Democrat David Roth,so they might end up with eight.
OK, so this is what i got when I told an AI image generator to give me a picture of “Polling Place.” Methinks our godlike Tech Wizards still have some work to do.
Anyway, it’s a few minutes before 7:00, and this is just to let you know that I’ll be sitting in front of my computer this evening, liveblogging about the Vermont returns as they come in. Expect a few races to be called right after the polls close, likely including U.S. Congress, Attorney General, Auditor, Secretary of State, and Treasurer, and probably including Lieutenant Governor. Stick around!
7:05 p.m. No votes counted yet, but I can tell you that 171,750 Vermonters cast votes before Election Day. In the last midterm year, the total vote in Vermont was around 286,000.
7:11 p.m. For the record, the Republican Governors Association’s tame IE-PAC, A Stronger Vermont, reported spending a total of $1,002,665.83 in this election cycle on ads attacking Amanda Janoo and supporting Gov. Phil Scott. That’s more money than either candidate spent on their own campaigns. No wonder people think that politics is full of lies and negativity; what they see of the campaigns is mostly these independent expenditures that are more about tearing down than building up. More than half the money was spent on TV ads ($517K); the second largest category was online advertising ($263K), and the third was payments to political consultancies ($151K).
7:35 p.m. A smattering of votes is in. Janoo has a two-percentage-point lead over Scott with about 5% of all votes counted. All the other Democrats on the statewide ballot are off to huge leads over their Republican opponents, including Molly Gray over Lt. Gov. John Rodgers. The Associated Press has yet to call any of the Vermont races except for legislative seats where only one major party fielded a candidate.
7:41 p.m. Scott takes a 5 1/2 point lead over Janoo with 10% of ballots counted. Scott beat Janoo by 16 points in Williston, which might be a worrying figure for the Democrat.
7:45 p.m. The biggest margins of all in early returns are for the two constitutional amendments. Prop 3 (collective bargaining rights) has a nearly 3-to-1 lead, and Prop 4 (equal protection) has a 4-to-1 lead. Only 3-4% of votes counted in those races.
7:50 p.m. Scott’s lead balloons to 11 points with 19% of all votes counted. Most of the returns are from small towns in conservative areas, although the governor is leading Janoo in some suburban Chittenden County communities. He won in St. Johnsbury by 12 points; Vermont’s other cities have yet to report except that Burlington has counted 17% of its ballots. Those votes went to Janoo by more than a 2-to-1 margin.
7:53 p.m. The AP called the Congressional race for incumbent Becca Balint over The Artist Formerly Known As Scary Eagle Man.
7:55 p.m. Upset alert? In the two-seat Caledonia-Essex House district, Democrat Amanda Cochrane has a big lead with 79% of the votes counted. She’s at 32%, while the other three candidates (incumbent Republican Rep. Deborah Dolgin, her husband Steven, and Democrat Heather Whitemore Young) are bunched together within a half a percentage point. Could St. Johnsbury actually send two Democrats to the House??
7:59 p.m. Some tantalizing state Senate results in the “way too early to call” category. The two Democrats are leading in both Addison and Bennington, which would be a net Democratic pickup of one seat in Addison. Dem Kim Gleason leads Republican Sen. Pat Brennan in Grand Isle, and former senator Irene Wrenner leads Rep. Ashley Bartley in the Chittenden North Senate district. And independent Dave Wolk is in second place in Rutland, which currently sends three Republicans to Montpelier. Too soon to call any of those races, but early hopes for Democrats.
Well, there it is. The last (I think) pre-election poll in the race for Vermont governor. And yes, that’s Democrat Amanda Janoo holding an eight-point lead over Gov. Phil Scott, comfortably beyond the poll’s margin of error and a tick north of the all-important 50% mark.
The poll comes from the University of New Hampshire Survey Center, and must be accompanied by a couple of caveats. First, the UNH results have been more Janoo-friendly* than the single Vermont Public poll or the ongoing efforts of State Navigate. Second, I’m not sure the Center believes its own product. Its report was headlined “Blue Wave Lifts Janoo Over Scott in Vermont?”
*The Center’s latest Maine poll shows Democrat Troy Jackson with a nine-point lead over incumbent Republican Sen. Susan Collins. Either this will be a true wave election, or UNHSC will have some cleaning up to do.
That’s right, they attached a question mark to their own headline. It’s as if they can’t really believe the results of their own work.
Also worth noting, or puzzling over: The survey’s respondents don’t believe it themselves! 62% of all respondents, including 40% of Janoo voters, predict that Scott will win. Which is very close to where the prediction markets are heading. As recently as September 22, 94% of all bets predictions on Kalshi were for Scott. The governor’s share of the Kalshi action is now at 66% and Janoo is at 34%.
An actual apology — one that fulfills the definition of the word — is a rare and precious thing. People who make public apologies, especially politicians, never put their hearts and souls into the task. Instead, it’s something they feel obliged to do, and they do a piss-poor job of it.
Take Gov. Phil Scott, who made an unforced error during the third and final debate of the gubernatorial campaign, broadcast on WCAX-TV and now viewable online. Scott was asked a question about education funding. His response included an obvious falsehood about the Winooski school district. His general point was that the quality of public education is too variable and that every student deserves equal opportunity. His answer also, as is his wont, pitted rural Vermont versus its more settled areas.
When you look at the Brigham Decision, it was about equalized education in all parts of the state. They decided to do it by the cost of education, and that’s been hampering some of the rural areas of the state where some have one or two languages being offered, whereas in Winooski and some of the Chittenden County areas, they have 17. That’s not an equal education, and we need to do better.
Well, that would be a troubling disparity if true. But it isn’t, at all. The Winooski school board issued a statement saying that in fact, it only offered courses in one language (French), not 17. The board called Scott’s assertion a “dog whistle” meant to stir up rural Vermonters over alleged “special treatment for a district that looks different from theirs.”
Well, the last pre-election campaign finance deadline has come and gone, and the big news is that the unknown underdog newbie pick-your-own-disparaging-descriptor Amanda Janoo has cleared seven figures in total fundraising.
That’s right, we’re talking Dr. Evil money. Janoo continued her late-stage sprint with an impressive haul of $170,000 in the last 15 days, for a grand total of $1,057,389.86 in donations.
Gov. Phil Scott, the invincible incumbent, has raised a much less impressive $720,000 including $130,000 in the most recent period. Of course, he entered the campaign with a hefty stash remaining from his 2024 walkover win, so he’s been able to spend $804,000 in all.
But still, the bottom line is this: Amanda Janoo has outraised and outspent Phil Scott for the entire campaign and in the most recent reporting period, covering the home stretch of the campaign. She’s received gifts from many more individuals than Scott, whose campaign has depended heavily on four-figure donations from the usual suspects in the business community. In her latest filing, Janoo reported receiving 26% of her total take in gifts of $100 or less. Scott, the alleged man o’ the people, got only 5% of his total in donations of $100 or less. (26% may seem low, but it’s actually a very respectable number. Most politicians don’t get that much from small donors.)
Gov. Phil Scott’s office has announced an energy partnership with Nova Scotia that could lead to Vermont getting a lot of its electricity from offshore wind farms planned for the ocean southeast of the Canadian province.
It’s a nice bit of pre-election publicity, seeking to rub some of the tarnish off Scott’s dismal record on renewables at a moment when he needs to shore up his centrist support. Doesn’t it sound great? A new source of cheap, clean power that doesn’t clutter up our own landscape? What could be better?
But there are spiders aplenty in this highly speculative attic, even if you leave aside the gross hypocrisy of Phil Scott advocating for wind power. To begin with, this is a three-year agreement concerning a development that will take at least twice that long to build — if it happens at all. And the press release itself, designed to put the best possible spin on this agreement, is heavily laden with qualifiers. Italics in the next paragraph are mine:
The headline touts the deal as “an agreement to explore bringing offshore wind power to New England through Vermont.” The agreement “establishes a framework for collaboration” on energy development. It “opens a path” to clean energy that “could help hold down electricity costs.” Access to New England markets “could support investment and jobs in the province.” The agreement “will support information sharing and explore opportunities” to bring wind energy “to New England through Vermont.”
Explore. Framework. Opens a path. Opportunities. Could. Could. All that from the office that’s doing its best to put the best face on this deal.
Now let’s do a quick map check. Yeah, “to New England through Vermont” makes no geographic sense at all. Distance from Halifax to Montpelier: 679 miles. From Halifax to Boston: 409 miles. The most direct line to New England is decidedly not through Vermont. And New England’s biggest electricity markets are in Massachusetts, Rhode Island, and Connecticut.That’s the shortest possible route for transmission lines and the most lucrative potential markets. Is Nova Scotia really going to bypass all of that to take a 270-mile detour through little ol’ Vermont?
We’re getting very close to “Aside from that, Mrs. Lincoln, how was the play?” territory. And that’s before we even get to the question of whether Nova Scotia will ever build a vast array of ocean-based turbines, not to mention how much the power would cost after considering the price tag for turbine construction and hundreds of miles of transmission lines.