The Phil Principle

Gov. Phil Scott just announced a couple of cabinet appointments that illustrate one of the problems with long-serving governors: Their best people move on, and the talent pool shrinks until it’s shallow and brackish.

This tendency is magnified with Scott because, throughout his tenure, he has usually played “next person up” when there’s a top-level vacancy. The deputy replaces a departed boss, or an established functionary moves from one place to another. Rarely has Scott hired from outside since he first assembled his team. The advantages are familiarity and loyalty. The disadvantage, if you do it over and over again, is you wind up with under-qualified people in critical positions.

It gets worse when a governor has already served multiple terms, because the gravy train is about to end its run. With Scott about to begin his all-time record sixth term (and having reportedly been reluctant to run for re-election this year), why would any qualified candidate with options choose to join a team likely to be disbanded in two years or less? You wind up shuffling and recycling because your options are few.

Which brings me to the 1969 pop nonfiction best-seller The Peter Principle. Its theory (originally meant to be satirical) was that in large organizations, good employees will earn promotions until they reach their level of incompetence. Then, if they’re terrible they get fired, but if they’re kind of adequate they’ll stick around. After a while, your entire team is full of people who can’t quite handle their jobs.

If we haven’t reached that point with Team Scott already, we’re perilously close. As VTDigger’s Shaun Robinson pointed out, roughly one-third of Scott’s cabinet has turned over so far this year. Anyone who lived through Peter Shumlin’s last term can tell you where this is going: the exodus will only grow because people need job security, and it’ll get harder and harder to find replacements of any quality.

See, for example, the Agency of Transportation, where the top two Jobs are being filled by interim administrators: Greg Knight, former adjutant general of the Vermont National Guard, is coming out of retirement to serve as Transportation Secretary for six months. Ditto Trini Brassard, a 30-year VTrans employee who will be Knight’s deputy for that same period.

I mean, if any state agency has to think long term, it’s VTrans. And it’s going to be led by people who will barely get their seats warm before they move on. This is nothing to do with their capabilities or qualifications, it’s a simple matter of managerial continuity. (The search for permanent successors at VTrans is almost doomed from the start because the near-universal assumption is that this will be Scott’s last go-round. We may get two full years of Knight and Brassard on rolling six-month appointments.)

For the other big vacancy, Scott is opting for the familiar: Brittney Wilson, who’s been in the administration since day one, is bumping up from deputy public service commissioner to the department’s number-one job. She’ll be replacing Kerrick Johnson who, love him or otherwise, knows more about Vermont’s electric power systems than anyone. Maybe Wilson will do just fine, but every time you shift a core functionary to a new post or promote from within, you risk activating the Peter principle.

Earlier this year another day-one Scott minion, Tayt Brooks, was promoted from deputy commerce secretary to the agency’s chief. Can he do the job? He probably won’t embarrass himself, but will he bring any fresh insight or expertise? I doubt it.

Of course, whenever I hear the name “Tayt Brooks” I can’t help but think of his first high-profile position: Running Vermonters First into the ground. For those just joining, Vermonters First was an independent expenditure PAC created in 2012 by conservative megadonor Lenore Broughton. She hired Brooks to run the thing, poured over a million dollars into it, and got absolutely bupkis for her troubles. 2012 turned out to be a big year for the Democrats in Vermont, marking Peter Shumlin’s all-too-brief high point as governor.

The other recent cabinet change came at the troubled Agency of Digital Services where the departed secretary, Denise Reilly-Hughes, was responsible for the disastrous Agency of Administration IT project that’s currently on pause because it’s in such deep trouble. Nobody knows how long it will take to complete, how expensive it will be, or if successful implementation is even possible. Well, her deputy, Andrea DeLaBruere, is now the interim secretary.

Maybe DeLaBruere will pull a rabbit out of a hat, but what are the chances? Giving her the interim tag isn’t exactly a vote of confidence, and how do you think a lame-duck governor is going to fare when he tries to hire a qualified IT expert to take over ADS?

All of these people will do their best. Some may succeed. Some are likely to be space-fillers. But the governor has patched and filled his org chart for so long that it’s more sparkle than structural. There might not be any disasters — well, that AOA project is already a disaster — but will there be any clear, long-term thinking? From an administration already not known for clear, long-term thinking? Most likely, the last two years of the Scott era will be characterized by a slow-motion rush for the exits with the hope that nothing too terrible will happen before the next governor walks through the door.

Leave a Reply