Daily Archives: November 19, 2026

The Phil Principle

Gov. Phil Scott just announced a couple of cabinet appointments that illustrate one of the problems with long-serving governors: Their best people move on, and the talent pool shrinks until it’s shallow and brackish.

This tendency is magnified with Scott because, throughout his tenure, he has usually played “next person up” when there’s a top-level vacancy. The deputy replaces a departed boss, or an established functionary moves from one place to another. Rarely has Scott hired from outside since he first assembled his team. The advantages are familiarity and loyalty. The disadvantage, if you do it over and over again, is you wind up with under-qualified people in critical positions.

It gets worse when a governor has already served multiple terms, because the gravy train is about to end its run. With Scott about to begin his all-time record sixth term (and having reportedly been reluctant to run for re-election this year), why would any qualified candidate with options choose to join a team likely to be disbanded in two years or less? You wind up shuffling and recycling because your options are few.

Which brings me to the 1969 pop nonfiction best-seller The Peter Principle. Its theory (originally meant to be satirical) was that in large organizations, good employees will earn promotions until they reach their level of incompetence. Then, if they’re terrible they get fired, but if they’re kind of adequate they’ll stick around. After a while, your entire team is full of people who can’t quite handle their jobs.

Continue reading →