Anyone noticed the lack of activity lately from the Ethan Allen Institute? What used to be the closest thing to an idea factory for Vermont conservatism has all but fallen off the map.

Turns out, it’s not your imagination. Here’s how inactive the Institute has been — and for how long.

Its website lists former Senate candidate Jack McMullen as chair of its board. I reached out to McMullen, who told me he resigned as chair in… wait for it… September of 2023.

Yep, more than two years ago, and nobody has bothered to update the website on something as important as the Institute’s top officeholder.

Other evidence of inactivity: The Institute’s website doesn’t list any paid staff. The most recent post on the Institute’s Facebook page is dated March 2023. There’s been only one entry on the Institute’s “Blog” page since January 2024, when longtime EAI stalwart John McClaughry (still listed as the Institute’s vice president, for all that’s worth) announced the end of his long-running series of biweekly commentaries on the page. The Institute has yet to file an IRS 990 form for 2024, which was due in October. And, of course, they’re still listing McMullen as chair more than two years after he resigned.

“[The Institute is] in a dormant stage,” McMullen told me. The cause, he asserted, is the ongoing litigation involving Myers Mermel, who served as president of the Institute for 10 months before being ousted by the board in, ahem, September of 2023. (Also in September 2023, as reported at the time by VTDigger: The State Policy Network, a national organization of state-level conservative think tanks, suspended Ethan Allen Institute’s affiliate status. Currently, SPN’s website lists no affiliation with any Vermont organization.)

Mermel, now owner of WDEV Radio, filed suit for wrongful termination after his dismissal. According to McMullen, the action is still making its way through the courts. “Litigation is very expensive,” McMullen noted, “Representation is costly.”

That’s as may be, but you’d think an organization with deep roots and a well-connected board would be able to walk and chew gum at the same time. The lawsuit can’t possibly be the only issue.

This situation came to my attention a few weeks ago when Common Sense Radio ended its long run as the conservative-branded hour on WDEV Radio. The Institute had paid for the airtime for years, but chose not to renew its contract according to Mermel. (He otherwise declined to comment on the record.) The time slot is now in the hands of the Vermont Daily Chronicle’s Guy Page.

My view: The increasingly radical nature of conservative politics may have sidelined the Institute, whose stock in trade was old-fashioned fiscal conservatism and free-market capitalism. I rarely (if ever) agreed with McClaughry or any of the Institute’s other commentators, but they never engaged in conspiratorialism or Trumpian authoritarianism and I respect them for that.

McMullen still has hopes for the Institute’s future. “I think they could revive if they get through the litigation,” he said. I hope they do. There was little to no common ground between the Institute and me, but it was a credible voice in Vermont politics. There’s a hole in our discourse where the Institute used to be.